Review: A Christmas Carol at Theatre by the Lake
“…truly wonderful production… will become the defining version for many…”

A Christmas Carol by Charles Dickens adapted by Matt Borgatti, Theatre by the Lake
By Ken Powell
You know that when Jacob Marley is dead then Christmas is nearly upon us. Marley’s ghost has certainly come to Keswick’s Theatre by the Lake and, I have to say, he’s in fine fettle for one who’s been dead for seven years.
Dead or not, this Marley takes much more of the lead than you would traditionally expect the poor spectre, weighed down with chains ‘forged in this life’, as he ‘leads the choir’ and guides the storyline. Matthew Burns cuts a particularly dashing version of Marley as he attempts to persuade his old friend and former business partner, the eponymous Ebenezer Scrooge, to turn from his selfish ways before it is too late.
The plot largely follows the traditional Dickens tale with all the spirits you would expect to appear on Christmas Eve. However, this new telling by Matt Borgatti plays a little with settings. Gone is Scrooge’s home. Instead, he finds himself in a ruined church where Marley plays choirmaster and the audience is the congregation. Circling around pulpit and pews, Scrooge’s life is played out right to the very bitter end. Such a variation on the story gives the excuse for many a song to be sung.
The songs themselves have been written by Will Dollard and Mary Erskine who, with Matt Borgatti, make up Goblin, a theatre production company that brought The Lost Spells to us at TBTL a few years ago. I always have a little worry when new musicals are produced. Dreadful songs can completely wreck an otherwise excellent performance and, alas, I’ve seen a few like that. No fear here though – Dollard and Erskine have done a fine job with catchy songs that linger with you and are well-crafted pieces.
It is now starting to get a little silly how TBTL, more than any other theatre I know, manages to find such multi-talented musical actors who seemingly can pick up an instrument and play it brilliantly. They really are taking the Tiny Tim a bit with yet another actor (in this case, Eleanor Toms) who can play a cello with it clasped in her arms as she wanders around. I mean, c’mon! I cry in my best Ebenezer voice, “For the love of all that’s sacred can you stop hiring outrageously talented performers and find some second-rate ones for once so that the rest of us can feel slightly less inadequate in life?”
But no, TBTL don’t listen to me (wisely, perhaps) and keep building this rather special reputation. A Christmas Carol is now part of a proud pantheon of productions over the years that delight in showing off all that their actors can do.

The seven-strong cast are all very definitely talented and whirl around the stage so fast it is almost a blur at times. It is the scripting rather than any lack of skill though that places two in particular above the others into the audience’s minds. Matthew Burns, as I say, has an unusually long role as Marley but he almost steals the show. Scrooge and Marley may have been their business when the moneylender was alive, but it was Scrooge and Marley: The Musical tonight! Borgatti and Burns have shown us that Dickens could have done much more with this character.
And then there is Scrooge himself, played by the surprisingly young-looking Neal Craig, though he looks anything but young on the stage. With a voice that repeatedly made me think of Bernard Cribbins, this Scrooge was convincing as the miserly old man but also comical throughout so that his transformation at the end seems entirely plausible. A most enjoyable Scrooge.
The show has clearly been created with young audiences in mind, just as Christmas productions should be. Sometimes one can feel you’re watching a kids’ show and it isn’t really meant for you. Other times some shows can go over the heads of children while the adults enjoy them more. This production of A Christmas Carol manages to get the balance pretty much right with jokes and fun on stage successfully appealing to all ages, while resisting the urge to become slapstick. With the slight caveat that I thought the puppet version of Tiny Tim was the most disturbing I’ve ever seen (not something I thought I’d ever write), there’s nothing in this version that should alarm young ones, at least until the final ghost who is, as it should be, wonderfully menacing.
Which leads me on to say that such menace was down, in part, to the combined work of Carla Goodman as set and costume designer, Jane Laljee as lighting designer and Joe Dines as sound designer. Together, they created a seamlessly magical production that just got better and better as the show progressed. It’s been a while since I’ve seen these disciplines rely so heavily on each other to make it work. Well done to their teams. There were times when it looked like we were watching a movie.
Indeed, you may feel you’ve seen everything you can see with Scrooge, Marley, ghosts and all. With countless movie versions (my family will certainly be enjoying the Muppets version this Christmas, as we do each year!), what can a stage version add? Well, clearly it makes its mark on young members. I overheard an audience member speaking to another as we left the auditorium for the interval, saying, “Yes, my son is really enjoying it. He’s on the edge of his seat!” That made me smile. This is a truly wonderful production and I have no doubt that TBTL’s version of A Christmas Carol will become the defining version for many young audience members this year. And so it should.

A Christmas Carol plays at Theatre by the Lake until Sunday, 3 January 2027. Tickets are available here.
Ken Powell is chief editor for Northern Arts Review and is also a bestselling author and writer for various publications around the world. A former school teacher, he continues to write educational books along with fiction and travelogues. You can find all his books and various websites here including his popular TEDx talk about the Global Village. He lives with his family in a wonderfully isolated village in West Cumbria where he enjoys drinking tea, chatting with the birds and winding up his dog. You can support his work (or just buy him a coffee) here.
