Review: A Simply Beastly Murder at Montgomery Theatre Sheffield
“Absolutely spiffing fun…”

A Simply Beastly Murder by Rachel E. Thorn, Montgomery Theatre, Sheffield
By Phil Scown
The set is sparse, the backdrop black. There are a few boxes, a stool and a hatstand. Music plays that you can recognise from detective films of the black-and-white era. A man enters, wearing a hat and a blood-spattered raincoat. The film noir setting is complete. Our man, Richard (Alistair Mackay), is a private detective. He’s soon joined by his sister, Anne (Rachel E. Thorn). Dick is evocative of Raymond Chandler’s private dick, Philip Marlowe. Tired, worn and cynical, he has to work the case with his innocent sister, though Anne has capabilities that would make her a candidate for the role of Jane Bond. Together, these two Famous Five characters work the case to its conclusion. Along the way, there are foreign-accented villains and many other set pieces that fit into both Enid Blyton’s children’s stories and Raymond Chandler’s detective fiction. There is sharp wit and humour in the physical comedy and the one-line gags that rapidly follow each other. Behind all this are issues of loss of empire, loss of innocence, arrested development and the nature of truth. In the tradition of film noir, there are powerless characters who make poor decisions, with no good options open to them.
Rachel E. Thorn and Alistair Mackay are very well paired as Anne and Dick. They are supported by the voice of Alistair McGowan. You might know Thorn and McGowan from BBC Radio Four comedy shows Dead Ringer and The Now Show. This cast of two makes great use of special effects and techniques to fill the stage with other characters. For example, there is a hilarious fight scene, achieved by ********* and ***************. A different technique, *********, is used to portray the swarthy villains. More fun is had when romantic scenes use ******** and **** very convincingly. Magical, it brings the house down. Sorry – spoilers are strictly forbidden by the team. I could tell you more, but then they’d have to kill me…

The lighting and sound departments, however, I can talk about freely and both are worth a special mention. The lighting department does sterling work to create a noir atmosphere and to support the various special effects described in detail above. At one point, Anne has eyes reminiscent of a Terry Gilliam cartoon character, which is powerful in the moment. Ed Heaton on sound ensures every word is heard and also contributes to the effects used to make this production so funny.
Interestingly, the tone of the last five minutes differs from that of the preceding fifty-five minutes of very funny entertainment. This switch jarred for me, but it may have been the intention of the author, Rachel E. Thorn, perhaps to conclude in keeping with the noir theme. That aside, I would recommend seeing A Simply Beastly Murder when it goes out on tour in the new year. If you were brought up on The Famous Five with Dick and Anne, Julian and George – not forgetting Timmy the dog – then you’ll feel right at home.
Though the show is only an hour long, it is packed with action that both surprises and makes you laugh. Seeing this show is a great start to a night out on the town. Absolutely spiffing fun, with lashings of tinned pineapple. Touring early next year, go and see A Simply Beastly Murder.

A Simply Beastly Murder plays at Montgomery Theatre Sheffield on 29 September.
Phil Scown has been a regular theatre-goer since his student days many years ago. Mysteries, thrillers, ghost stories, comedies and musicals are all part of his theatre diet. Phil writes short stories in a variety of genres, some of which have become screenplays. He likes to tour England, Scotland and France, nowadays by car rather than motorcycle. At other times Phil likes to cook and to drive his Caterham, though generally not at the same time.

