Review: The Moth at Live Theatre, Newcastle
“…evocative and as deeply human as it is disturbing…”

The Moth by Paul Herzberg, Live Theatre, Newcastle
By Melina Turner-Deeks
The Moth is an intimate play that explores themes of race, war, redemption and legacy. The play began as a short monologue (inspired by a true story), as part of northern theatre company Elysium’s Covid-19 Monologues, which was featured in 26 international film festivals and won multiple awards. Expanding it into a feature-length play was obviously the next step, and its relocation to the stage was a gripping success. Paul Hertzberg’s script is evocative and as deeply human as it is disturbing.
Live Theatre, a cosy independent theatre nestled within sight of the River Tyne on Newcastle’s quayside, provided a wonderfully welcoming space. Finding a comfy spot in one of the cosy bar areas is a great way to prepare for the show, as is grabbing a quick bite at St Vincent, a charming wine-bar-cum-restaurant that is attached to the theatre. The performance space itself was very plush, with both cabaret-style tables and chairs surrounding the stage and large comfortable cinema chairs. Upon arrival in the auditorium, quiet atmospheric music set a slightly foreboding tone as we found our seats. The thrust stage featured two banners stating the word ‘Confessional’, featuring the face of John Josana (Faz Singhateh).
The set design (by Amelia Mitchell) was simple and ingeniously adaptable, allowing it to be quickly and easily reworked to serve as both train carriage and office. Hatstands in each corner held the small number of costume changes that flawlessly allowed monologues to introduce other characters or time periods. The lighting (by Simon Cole) and sound (by Paul G. Clark) were simple yet dramatic allowing the audience to really focus on the characters and differentiate between their internal and external struggles.

The performance began with loud, news-style music, and the words ‘Unfiltered Truth’, setting the stage as some sort of confessional news programme that revealed the truth of an ongoing matter. The play features only two characters: John Josana (Faz Singhateh), a Black British journalist and activist, the son of a South African refugee; and Marius Muller (Micky Cochrane), a White South African ex-soldier, and son of a Nazi officer. The (physically and politically) opposing characters meet by chance on a train journey, one that changes both of their lives and irreversibly interweaves them in a way they would never expect. The performance merges dialogue and dramatic monologues, so that we hear the surface conversations that the characters share but also gain insight into the characters’ history, thoughts, and inner turmoil and trauma. This highlights the complexities of war, race and toxic masculinity, and illustrates the mental burden that must be carried by survivors on either side.
Singhateh and Cochrane both gave incredible performances throughout. Faz Singhateh gave a stoic performance as John Josana, perfectly capturing the trauma dredged up against his will. Micky Cochtrane did really well to give depth and reality to an almost unlikable Marius Muller, evoking compassion for the role of the racist ex-soldier, whose characterisation was truly three-dimensional.
Throughout The Moth, both characters unsuccessfully grapple with themes of repentance, atonement and forgiveness, as well as ideas of history and legacy. One profound aspect that stood out was each character’s lack of choice. People are born into their roles in the world and often have little free will over their path through life, depending on where, when and how they were born and raised. Race and place can sometimes determine how you live, love, and hate. At the same time, redemption and resolve can be found – or at least sought – in the most unlikely of places and people. This play wrestles with large, heavy and complex issues and resists the temptation to simplify anything, creating more moral quandaries and questions than it solves. The bottom line is that in war, no one comes out a winner.
A sure sign of a remarkable and powerful play is that it stays with you, long after the curtain call. Like the moth, this play will linger and flutter in your mind.

The Moth plays at Live Theatre until Saturday 15 March.
Melina Turner-Deeks is a poet and self-confessed literature nerd. She currently runs literary workshops and bookclubs in North Tyneside as The Literature Lass. When she is not baking, parenting or reading, she loves being outdoors and connecting with nature. Find her on Instagram here or Facebook here.

